NachoNacho
NachoNacho

Justworks vs OnPay

Justworks suits teams seeking a PEO with HR and benefits support; OnPay suits teams that want full-service payroll with optional HR and time-tracking tools. Both offer payroll and access to group health plans, but their plans work differently: Justworks sells Payroll and PEO tiers, while OnPay starts with Payroll Essentials and lets businesses add services.

Last updated November 17, 2026.

At a glance

Justworks compared with OnPay, one row per dimension
DimensionJustworksOnPay
Plan structurePayroll, PEO Basic, PEO Plus, EORPayroll Essentials with optional add-ons
Payroll pricePayroll: $8/employee/month plus $50/month base fee$49/month base plus $6/worker/month
PEO service pricePEO Basic: $79/employee/month; Plus: $124/employee/monthNot published
International hiringEOR: $599/employee/monthNot published
Time tracking price$8/employee/month add-on$15/month base plus $4/worker/month add-on
Group health optionsPEO Plus; Payroll $8/benefits-eligible employee/month add-onGroup plans; plan premiums only
PEO medical-plan minimumTwo eligible employees enrolled, from different householdsNot published
HR support24/7 support on PEO plansWeekday support; live HR support $65/month add-on
IntegrationsQuickBooks and Xero on Payroll and PEOQuickBooks Online and Xero
Employee mobile appiOS and AndroidiOS and Android
Payroll runsOff-cycle paymentsUnlimited pay runs
Additional HR toolsHR tools on Payroll; HR consulting on PEOHR add-on: $15/month base plus $2/worker/month

Scroll the table sideways to compare each row.

Which should you choose?

Justworks logo

Choose Justworks if

  • Teams seeking a PEO alongside payroll
  • Employers wanting PEO medical-plan access
  • Businesses hiring international employees through an EOR
  • Teams needing 24/7 support on PEO plans
See Justworks — 25% CASHBACK
OnPay logo

Choose OnPay if

  • Businesses starting with full-service payroll
  • Teams that want to add HR or time tracking separately
  • Employers seeking unlimited pay runs in the base plan
  • Businesses wanting phone, email, and chat support with payroll
See OnPay

The verdict

Justworks is the better fit when PEO services, 24/7 PEO support, or international employee hiring belong on the shortlist. OnPay is the better fit when the business wants to start with payroll, then add HR, time tracking, compliance resources, or live HR support as needed. Compare the full cost of the services you would use, including health-plan premiums, rather than the payroll starting prices alone.

Justworks vs OnPay: common questions

Which costs less for payroll alone, Justworks or OnPay?
Justworks Payroll costs $50 per month plus $8 per employee; OnPay Payroll Essentials costs $49 per month plus $6 per worker. Add-ons and benefits can change the total for either product.
Does OnPay offer the same PEO option as Justworks?
Justworks publishes PEO Basic at $79 per employee per month and PEO Plus at $124 per employee per month. OnPay publishes Payroll Essentials and optional services, but does not publish a PEO plan.
Can I get group health insurance without buying Justworks PEO Plus?
Yes. Justworks offers health insurance as an $8-per-benefits-eligible-employee monthly add-on to its Payroll plan. OnPay offers group health plans with no separate benefits-administration fee; plan premiums still apply.
Are health insurance premiums included in Justworks PEO pricing?
No. Justworks’ published PEO fees are administrative fees; health insurance is priced through a separate, customized quote.
What is the minimum enrollment for Justworks PEO medical plans?
Justworks requires at least two benefits-eligible employees from different households to enroll in its PEO medical plans. That enrollment minimum does not apply to its dental and vision plans.
How much does time tracking cost with each product?
Justworks Time Tracking costs $8 per employee per month as an add-on. OnPay Time Tracking costs an additional $15 monthly base fee plus $4 per worker per month; OnPay also lists a discounted bundle combining payroll, HR and time tracking.
Which offers support outside weekday hours?
Justworks lists 24/7 support on its PEO plans. OnPay includes phone, email and live chat support for payroll clients during its published extended weekday hours of 9 a.m. to 8 p.m.
Can either product hire employees internationally?
Justworks publishes an employer-of-record service for international employees at $599 per employee per month. OnPay does not publish an international employer-of-record offering.